Writers' Intl. Forum's
Winning Manuscript

   
Cinderella: How it Really Happened

By Kelsey Brosnan
(10 years old)

Special Young Authors Award

    Everyone knows the story of Cinderella, the kind, sweet, generous sister who did all the work. Yeah, right. Everyone knows that story. But do they know what really happened?

     I should think I would know. I'm Cinderella's fairy godmother. Or the fairy tales say. But you can forget all that. Fairies died out with the dinosaurs. They just don't exist. But just a plain old grandma helping out her dopey little granddaughter isn't a very exciting story, so... let's just say our story got a little messed up.

     What really happened was just this: once--I refuse to say "Once upon a time for a good reason"--there lived--and still do--a mother, whose name is Joan, and her two daughters, whose names are Paula and Veggitina. They aren't perfect angels, but the way the author of the original story put it, they sound like demons. That isn't actually the case. They are pretty nice, and although they aren't real beauties, they work their share and are, in most ways, just like you and me.

     Now, these ladies live in Kentucky. No, not in England, not in France, but in Kentucky. They are pretty happy living there. Then one day this farmer came along. He wasn't rich, and he certainly wasn't poor. He and his daughter Ellen had moved from place to place, and had finally decided to settle in Kentucky, don't ask me why. He settled...surprise, surprise...right next to Joan's farm.

     After a while, the farmer, my son, who does have a name, but I will not say it, married Joan. Ellen was a little skeptical. Her mother had died, and having a new mother didn't help. But it wasn't her choice, her father told her, and she had better keep quiet. So without a word--and the occasional groan--they moved into Joan's place. Ellen, who was later christened "Cinderella" by those who were oblivious to the real story, wasn't really all that nice. She wasn't that mean, but altogether, she really wasn't your favorite person. She was pretty, that's for sure. She did her share of the work. That's true, so I can't blame her for that. But she didn't seem all that enthusiastic about it.

     So one day, out of the blue, one of Paula's friends invites Paula and Veggitina to a party. Ellen had just moved in, so of course not everyone knew her. But she got all mad because she wasn't invited. Her parents got fed up and went out to dinner so they could have some peace and quiet. I don't blame them.

     So I show up. Not by magic. Not just appearing. No. I climbed into my new red convertible and drove over there. And I didn't know a thing about what was going on with this birthday stuff. I just came over for the fun of showing off my car.

     Ellen was sitting on the deck, crying. Oh please, I thought, but went over to her anyway. After all, I was her grandmother.

     "Hi ya, Ellen. How ya doing? Hey, where is everyone?"

     "At...the party I wasn't invited to. They are having a great time while I get to stay here!"

     I was pretty skeptical of this. I mean, she could have made an effort to know some people and therefore been invited to their parties. But she hadn't. "Oh, well. Maybe next time, Ellen. Listen, is your mom home? I need to talk to her." Of course I didn't, really, but any excuse to get away from this weepy kid would help.

     "Nah, she went out too. With Dad. Now I'm here all alone. Say... you're a grandma."

     "Yeah." I looked at her. "Yeah, I'm a grandma."

     "I know that."

     "Then why did you say, 'Say...you're a--'"

     "I know, I know," she said hurriedly. "But in this story I read, this grandma can grant three wishes and stuff. Can you do that?"

     Now I thought she was completely crazy. But I decided to play along. "Hmm... yeah, OK, I guess I could."

     "Great! Well, my first wish is to--"

     "Hold on!" I shouted. "No way. One wish, please. Three wishes are too many for an old lady like me. Even Grandmas get tired once in a while."

     "All right. Well, my wish is...get me to that party! I've just got to go! Get me a new dress, new shoes, like the ones Paula has... and a limousine."

     "That's one wish?" I commented in exasperation. I sat down next to her. "Anyway, how are you going to get there without an invitation?"

     "That too." Ellen looked excited.

     I almost told her to forget it. "Well, I'd better get to work. When does the party start?"

     "Gee, it's already started."

     "When does it end?"

     "Well... it says on the invitation Paula and Veggitina got. I think it's... midnight."

     I glanced at my watch. It was eight o'clock. There was no time to lose. First, I got on Joan's phone. I called Joe's Limousine Service. "Hello? This is Wanda Bea Fairy here." Ellen's eyes became as large as saucers. "I would like a limousine to pick my granddaughter up at eight-thirty and drop her off at Joan McBeek's place. (Pause) Oh, you could? That's great. See you then!"

     I hung up. Now I needed to get the dress.

     I drove to Bellairs and got a beautiful red dress. It cost a fortune. In Paula's closet I found gorgeous shoes that didn't fit her anymore, but were just right for Ellen. Ellen was delighted.

     "Oh, boy, you're like the fairy godmother in the book! Great. Now I want the invitation. How do I get that?"

     I was stumped. Out of ideas. Kaput.

     "Gee, I don't know. You'll have to work that out for yourself. If anyone asks, say you're Paula's cousin. Listen, the limousine service works up to twelve o'clock. You've got to be finished dancing by then and go out and meet the driver. If you don't, the limousine will leave without you. OK? Great. Hey! There's the limousine! Good luck, kid. Remember at midnight!"

     "Midnight!" Ellen called back. With that she dove into the back seat of the limousine and drove off.

     I was pretty content. I mean, here I was, watching my granddaughter in a limousine, this whole empty house behind me, and no one home! Things aren't what they seem... especially with Grandmas.

     Well, Paula and Veggintina were having a blast at the party. The music was deafening; a fog machine poured smoke-like mist across the floor, and bright colored lights were swinging all over the place.

     When Ellen, who was looking pretty good--courteous moi--came into the room, everyone stopped dancing and looked at her. Not even the hostess noticed she hadn't invited her.

     After some time, the music started up again and Ellen danced her heart out. At midnight, everyone was admiring her and her dance moves. Suddenly Ellen remembered and ran out of the door, leaving behind one of her high heels. The hostess, whose name was Denise, rushed after her, picking up the shoe. "Wait!" she cried. " Where are you going?"

     Ellen hopped into the limousine just in time. As it was speeding down the hill, she sighed and wondered if she'd ever go to a party like that again. So Ellen came home, thanked me, put on her nightgown, and flopped on her bed.

     I knew Paula and Veggitina would be steaming if they knew what we had pulled off, so I tucked the dress under Ellen's bed and shoved the single shoe in the back of Paula's closet. "There," I said aloud and drove back home.

     The next afternoon Paula told Ellen about the announcement Denise had made during recess. "Whoever fit the shoe that had been left behind would be her best friend." Ellen nearly burst out shouting: Me! I was the one! But, of course, she couldn't.

     That same afternoon Denise came over and tested Veggitina. No such luck. The shoe fit like a size 2 fits a size 12.

     Paula tried it, but it was like trying to fit and elephant into an ant farm. Denise noticed something familiar about Ellen, who was sitting on the couch, watching. She called, "Hey girl, ya wanna try it on? It hasn't fit anyone yet. You guys are the last ones. Yeah, that's right. It doesn't fit anyone!!"

     Paula took a close look at the shoe. It was her shoe!

     Ellen tried it on. It fit! Denise whooped. But Paula pulled Ellen aside. "That was my shoe," she whispered.

     Ellen nodded weakly.

     Paula started to laugh. "Who helped you? I can't believe it!"

     "Grandma."

     "Hah! That is too funny. Figures... that grandma."

     The whole thing was explained to Denise. She was a little angry with being tricked but had to laugh about the shoe part. She became best friends with Vegitina, Paula, and Ellen.

     But don't say you know all this. I mean, who'd believe you? Take it from a "Fairy Grandmother." I know what I'm doing.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

   Kelsey Brosnan is a 10-year-old fourth-grader from New Jersey. In third grade she wrote several newspapers at home for fun and has written for her school newspaper for the last two years. She has been featured as a young writer in the "Our Times" kids' section of her community newspaper.

Kelsey says, "I keep a journal and write in it regularly, and I have written many other stories and often write plays for my family to perform."

EDITOR'S COMMENTS

Kelsey has chosen a favorite topic for many writers: taking a familiar story line and changing some aspect of it. In her case, she chose a popular fairy tale, Cinderella, and changed the setting, both place and time. The reason a turn-about story of this type is fun is that the reader can anticipate the plot and enjoys seeing how the author has changed it. The keys to successfully writing such a story are:

1. Chose a story that will be familiar to most readers.

2. Make at least one big alteration to change an important aspect of the plot. Kelsey eliminated an important aspect of the original story: she took out the magic!

3. Consider how other, smaller aspects of the plot require creative changes as a result of the big change. In this case, the coach (limousine) would not magically turn into a pumpkin at midnight because no magic was involved. So Kelsey had to think of another reason to make midnight the deadline for Ellen's night of fun.

4. The ending can be the same as the original but is usually more fun and satisfying with a distinct difference. For Ellen, there was no Prince Charming, just a great time learning to enjoy the company of friends.

One warning: Readers--and editors--usually come in two categories: those that like turn-about stories and those that don't. If you plan to market any story of this type, be sure to choose a publication that has printed turn-about stories before.

All in all, great fun! Thanks, Kelsey!

Want professional--and personal--feedback
on your own writing?
Click here for information on our
Professional Editing Services.

 
READER COMMENTS

Comments from a reader in New Jersey:
"I knew you were a great writer but never knew it was this good way back when. You should show this to Mr. Palowski; he'll go nuts. I feel very honored to have a piece of your writing, a poem you wrote for me in 5th grade. Maybe I'll just have to keep it forever. Keep writing!"
-- Sarah

Comments from a reader in New Jersey:
"While browsing on the Internet, I had the good fortune to come across your story. I knew you had a lot of talent while I was a teaching assistant in your third grade classroom and appreciate it even more now. Congratulations on getting your work published. I am sure I will someday be reading one of your books to my students!"
-- Daniel Berek

Comments from a reader in New Jersey:
"Kelsey, I'm very privileged to be your enrichment teacher and greatest supporter.  Your 'voice' in writing is exceptionally clear and mature.  I'm sure you can have a professional career in writing if that is your choice."
-- Mrs. Lester

Comments from a reader in South Carolina:
"Kelsey, are you sure you're just 10? What a fun, well-written story! I enjoy turn-around stories, and while I've read a number done on Cinderella, this is the first from the viewpoint of the 'fairy godmother.' Good going!"
--Brenda Covert

Reply from Kelsey's mom (printed with Kelsey's permission):
"I can assure you Kelsey just turned ten, but the content of her writing is often so beyond her years!  I find her story starts so intriguing and mature. What I nice compliment from the reader.  I know Kelsey will proud. You can be sure that I am! (And so is her dad.)"
--Marianne Brosnan

Response from our editor:
"It is a pleasure to deal with young writers - it has always been a highlight in our business.  I will, however, have to agree with the reader that sometimes I feel a bit intimidated by the high caliber of writing coming from these youngsters. Not that I doubt their age (we verify that) it just makes me realize how talented the young competition is that is nipping at our heels!"
--Sandra E. Haven


Writers love feedback! Click the mail box to send us an e-mail with your comments about this manuscript and we will gladly forward them to the author.
 
Return to Winning Manuscripts Index